Email response from FAR, page-79

Hi WN,

Thank you for this. I think your getting closer to real substantiation. But most of your statements/concerns are still what one would find from any first year petro-puppy.

"Tilted fault blocks work if you have a good seal, Do we?" Always a basic issue. What technical evidence/knowledge do you have that the seal/(s) may not be sufficiently or structurally competent?

"Oil charge still an issue although Fan 1 helps" . Yes it does...a lot in this case.

"Reservoir is the big one, it all speculation and based upon seismic porosity response and many thing can generate such an effect." Always a basic issue/always speculative (more so) in new basins. But why do you suspect or know that COP/CNE seismic interpretation has higher risk/lower quality than, say FAN-1?

Can you please elucidate your technical background and knowledge. It will certainly help toward establishing the credibility of your comments which I appreciate when evidenced.

Cheers,