Abu Dhabi meeting with CEO, page-43

Hottuna doth protest too much, methinks.

Are his arguments over-zealous and ultimately weak sauce or just plain incorrect?
Does he spend an inordinate amount of effort to downramp continuously?
As sandalwood stocks diminish at ever faster rates due to zero ecological management, does his Economics 101 Supply/Demand curve becomes a joke as pointed out by Mosb above?
He says he holds but is it clear he is being disingenuous and actually shorts?

(phrased as questions to avoid issues).