Alp franking credit changes I want a straight answer, page-256

  1. 7,773 Posts.
    lightbulb Created with Sketch. 362
    "From that I assume you agree that my answer to Moondongs question is correct ", actually no.

    These word games are fun!

    "Each fund (Retail/Industry/SMSF) is treated exactly the same" your answer
    Moon's question, "Two identical aged people with identical balances and identical portfolios.
    One in a smsf and one in an industry fund.

    Are they treated the same under the alp proposal or not?"

    Manifestly . the 2 aged people ,no.   See my past question.
    However you are quite right the funds are treated the same, but that wasn't the question.

    Now, back to my question, which was really just to pin you down . Thought I had
    How about both in pension phase super, would it shock you if that is what I meant?

    Now you seem an honorable lad, I hope you are not going to go for the "oh , look over there , a squirrel" defence , so beloved by HC participants.

                  cheers

 
arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch. arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch.