Blah, I was replying to "BBI shares can never get to 50 cents if the BEPPA's situation stays as it is". In my opinion, that is wrong. It is a, to me, clear downramp. "Never" is a long time. How is it fair to say "never". Imho, his statement is said like it is a fact. This is not a fact. It is an opinion. Stated as fact. As such, I have every right to strongly criticise his statement. That is all.
I only came onto HotCopper due to a Google Search for BBI. It's the share I've got most interest in. I've read all recent topics on HRR and MAK. I've also read several topics on ANZ and MQG and CNP. I hold just these shares ^.
I don't understand how you can then make a jump to conlcude that since I've only posted on BBI, I'm too attached to it. My wealth of knowledge with MQG, ANZ is much, much less. My wealth of knowledge on MAK is relatively low these days (I know semi-recent RP price, I know about BON, but thats about it).... I have just put CNP into the bottom draw. I can't contribute much to those threads (I hold just those stocks).
On the other hand, whilst my knowledge is outstripped by several people in this thread (Favro, Melua, Dargie all IMMEDIATELY come to mind)... i do know enough to present opinions and information about BBI. Hence why I contribute here.
I just don't like trash statements such as "BBI shares can never get to 50 cents if the BEPPA's situation stays as it is". That's just wrong, it's misinformation. His opinion is that BBI shares can't get there, if BEPPA stays the same. Or he thinks BBI probably won't get to 50c if it states the same.
Then you have Favro who is saying that in 2011 DBCT EBITA will be less than in 2010. ABN Amro has it increasing 10%, Favro has it decreasing 10%. I just have no idea why.
Again, both of those people know more about BBI than me. I respect both of them... it's just that Dargie gave misinformation, and I am really puzzled about Favro's claim (at least that is stated as an opinion, not fact).
Add to My Watchlist
What is My Watchlist?