Nah, I'm not taking the judgement out of context. Your quotes are irrelevant to my post to Joe.
It's not a matter of whether ASX's findings were accurate and ISX wrong or vice versa. It's who determines what's right? That's definitely not ASX.
My quote from the judgement supports that the 'findings' needed to be examined closely by a competent authority but until that was done, ASX needn't have released them. So if a competent authority determines they were wrong, wouldn't ASX have misled the market, which was ISX's argument?
ASX could have maintained an unbiased stance by either publishing both the SOR and ISX's response, considering the court ruled in their favour, or published nothing. But they did neither.
ISX Price at posting:
$1.07 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held