roche dismisses tamiflu criticism , page-6

Reading the report summary, I think they are having a go at anti-virals in general, not just Tamiflu... I may be wrong but the gist of the report is maybe the authorities shouldnt be using anti-virals in a big way (for otherwise healthy people) when their effects are 'modest' ie reduces symptons by 1 day... these issues have been raised many times over the years... probably applies to a lot of drugs on the market...

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/339/dec07_2/b5106