If you want to cherry pick as you are doing, you will get -> Two individuals, one God?
Thomas address's Jesus as Lord and says, and my God, referring to the God within Jesus. -> Believest thou not that I am in the Father, and the Father in me? the words that I speak unto you I speak not of myself: but theFather that dwelleth in me,he doeth the works.
Simple really. ----------- Two individuals, one God?
Interlinear -> John 1:18 - God no one has ever seen yet; the only begotten God,...............................
Yahweh is God and Jesus's father. That being the case, it is then showing two individual God's, not one as your suggesting.