Share
939 Posts.
lightbulb Created with Sketch. 4
clock Created with Sketch.
13/07/23
10:12
Share
Originally posted by MichaelUsername:
↑
"Why can't you get angles from a curved surface?" Ummm, an angle is two straight lines meeting at a vertex. That's why. This is fundamental stuff. "If you slice through the surface of a sphere, you will get different sized cross-sections..." Yes you would, and the cross sections would all be FLAT. So then you would be measuring angles from a flat baseline? Yes, that's what I have been saying all along. But nobody is cutting up sphere earths like oranges and measuring angles to stars. We measure the angles from the surface, so the surface must be flat. Don't shoot the messenger.
Expand
"But nobody is cutting up sphere earths like oranges and measuring angles to stars" True enough. But with just the slightest education, you can use accepted principles and techniques and act as though you can. And as a bonus... it works. Since your google seems to broken, please. Use mine.https://thenauticalalmanac.com/2017_Bowditch-_American_Practical_Navigator/Volume-_1/05-%20Part%203-%20Celestial%20Navigation/Part%203-%20Celestial%20Navigation.pdf This link will tell you more than you'll ever want to know about celestial navigation. Funny thing. The text string "flat" appears twice in that 119 page extract. In neither case is it followed by "earth". As an added bonus, this extract talks a little about the latitude errors introduced by using the angle to Polaris ... which in part comes down to the degree of precision you require.