ctp is considerably overvalued, page-10

Klass,

Im a non-holder who watched on enviously during CTPs recent action. I felt for holders during the latest SP fall -losing lots of cash like I have with others plays like ERJ and GBZ.

I have disliked anyone giving a negative assertion of a company without reasoning of some quality (more of those posts should be struck from the fourm), and I especially view with disdain those who love to mock others who have lost money.

The balancing view is that I have come to realise the benefit of posters with a negative viewpoint esp. if they provide logical or quality reasoning. Whether I agree with their reasoning or not is up to me, and I need to take into account that we are all pushing our own barrow even if subconsciously.

We are all entitled to our opinion, and providing we dont flame or vexatious we dont have to have formal financial qualifications to express our viewpoint Im not sure that accountants make the best investors.

We are all non-holders at some time (refer trading 101: exit strategy)doesnt mean that we do not have an interest.

I could well ask you what logic or reasoning you gave us to disagree with 5hareholders analysis, rather than disagreeing with his right to express it.

Im not trying to contentions here, but in the bigger picture Ive come to realise that those with a different viewpoint to mine can sometimes be my best friend.

I saw the "expected to flow to surface" ann. when it came out and didn't like the look of the motive for that ann. at the time, in hindsight I like it less and I suggest caution for the future.

Despite that caution, I genuinely hope CTPs get the positive news you have been anticipating.


John S.


ALL IMHO