placement, page-82

Hi GS

A couple of quick points:

Hi TT, thanks for your "quick" points. My replies are below each point.

1. You mention about Gassy sidestepping your question. I asked you a question a few months ago & still no reply. The question is 'What is your agenda here?' You have inferred in almost every post you have written that this company is not worth investing in and is unlikley to meet your investment criteria for years - if ever. So I can't help wondering why you spend your time on this thread. Genuine respect for posters such as Kingswood, Katok etc and others who at least at one point in time owned shares in PIE.

I suggest most people can understand why a PIE shareholder would regularly post and could even understand optimistic posting. I also suggest that most people could understand a non holder providing their opinion on the company and once having decided the company does not meet their investment standards, would move on.

I am here because I own shares - why are you? What is your motivation?


I could understand if you replied that it was to annoy Gassy, however then all could discount your comments accordingly.

Tiger, I'm sure Itsagas and Petunia will appreciate you leaping to their defence. However, as I have explained to your previously, I am trying to understand this company better with a view to investing, and am discussing valid point on a discussion forum - as happens on all other company threads on HC.

It is unfortunate that you believe that only positive views should preside. I have made valid predictions and they have all come to fruition - well more so than those spruiking everything that the company comes out with. I find it interesting that the wholly positive supporters are not giving their views on the 1.6c capital raising.

As for agendas, I put it to you, what is the agenda of those who dismiss or discuss anything construed as negative?



2. You quoted me in your above post as follows:

."Why would Pie go into TRADING HALT for 3 days for a CR to raise a mere $1 or 2 Mill?....Pie put out the UPDATE to inform shareholders of the Enormous growth in the year to follow.So i feel the TH was for a reason ,my feeling is that we are all going to be surprised and as TT has said ,the sp could open up over 3c.

At no stage did I state the SP could open above 3c. Can you quote your source of this information please.



No I did not quote you. They were all quotes from Itsagas. Reread my post.

I did make comments that I believe SP could possibly be over 3c now if it wasn't for current global economic conditions and the impact on spec stocks.

See previous point, but in response to your 3c view, I'm afraid that the current global economic conditions applies to all companies. You comment is basically suggesting that if we had continued with a massive credit fuelled boom, the price would be much higher. Along the same lines, I make the argument that if I had played cricket from age 3, I would be representing Australia by now. You see, it doesn't matter. We are where we are. It is what it is. Good companies have share prices that excel. Other don't.

You also had a go at Petunia about misrepresenting your timing of comments about TZL. Surely this is hipocrisy on high.

No I didn't. Reread my post.

Finally, your comment:

'Good to see Gassy and Petunia holding the fort. Most of the PIE faithful don't even waste their time defending PIE anymore.

No Opel, those people have common sense and are rightly defending their savings instead. PIE faithful....geeez!!'

To make representations like this on behalf of all holders who don't respond to negativity from someone who is anti PIE & has demonstrated hipocrisy in the past is breathtaking.

Well please get your breath back because there is no need to lose it if you don't understand a point. Investing is not like cheerleading or barracking for your favourite footy team. Each investor is selfish and out to make as much money as possible...unless you are different. It is the name of the game. Opel was questioning loyalty or shareholders. As far as I'm concerned, loyalty shouldn't come into investing.

Maybe all of us PIE holders who are inclined to do so could begin providing our opinions on the failings of TZL in the same spirit you have with PIE?

Sure feel free! There is plenty of such discussion on there. Note that the key word it discussion

Good luck to all holders.

TT

Yes. Good luck. But more importantly 'Good judgement'