Ann: 11.10.11 CTP's WA Amadeus Applications , page-33

re: Ann: 11.10.11 CTP's WA Amadeus Applic... Dear Anonymous1

I note that you appreaciate that I am entitled to take a position that accords with my investment strategy, as you and any other person, are entitled to make even if they are diametrically apposed to mine.

If my comments are as you portray them a "mantra" then I respectfully suggest that I am entitled to make such comments, unless of course you have been promoted to that hallowed status of "Hot Copper Moderator".

I note that you rarely if ever make comments about other peoples "negative mantra" , but for some reason known only to yourself chose to make public comment about my so called "mantra".

The fact that you have in your words " witnessed this behaviour from many investors on overseas forums and it doesn't do anybody any good" is clearly an observation made by a person who is less than objective.

How you have managed to come to the definitive conclusion that "it doesn't do anybody any good" is beyond my limited comprehension.

I note that you do not provide any facts to support your assertion, but simply make the all knowing blanket statement and ask readers to accept what you say without question.


Not only do you make the above unsubstantiated comments, but by implication you assert that the management of Central; Petroleum fall within the category of being "Bad apples and Crooks, together with Incompetent Management destroy any chance a company had of becoming great."

How you have again managed to arrive at your assertion that the management of Central are;Bad apples, Crooks, or Incompetent Management, and as a consequence are holding Central Petroleum from realising its full potential is simply beyond my comprehension.

You appear to make extremely serious and outrageous comments that are not supported by any factual matters,in an attempt to vent your spleen.

I agree that healthy criticism is a desirable and natural product of living in democracy, as is any persons right to support and take issue with unsupported and outrageous downramping and slurs upon management.

Your implied assertion that my posts somehow stifle "healthy criticism" is refuted. The very fact that you posted your post and I respond is nothing more than a democratic environment working as it should.

For the record, I do not think that any one on HC is an idiot.

In regards to your motives, for posting such a hostile post, perhaps the final paragraph indicates more about you as a person than you may realise.

"Or do you just sit in the back right hand corner of all CTP presentations and keep an eye on JH and ask the questions that need to be asked."

I presume (and please correct me if I am wrong) that the intent of you making such comment was to imply that you ( or another) had been at a presentation and that you had some how managed to identify me sitting in that location.

The implication of your comment, is clearly to be interpreted as being " I know who you are and what you look like" If I am wrong be advise.

Dear oh dear, Mr Anonymous1 time for a reality check methinks.

CB