Who criticised who? All Musashi did was make statement that you can make money on a down days or stocks that get traded down sharply and then bounce of S3 pivot on the intraday m5 to set up a bounce trade... I've never once read a post by musashi claiming he was this masterful trader, but he does contribute with good T/A on this forum... More the fact Musashi has posted on stock saying it is going to move before it does move, not like some who post after the stock has moved...