I agree with you. Gibb Maitland and even Blatchford wells are quite different than Nicolay. I think they are both located on anticline and might have conventional upside as opposed to Nicolay.
You can see their locations (not exact though) on the 3D graphic (depth to basement map) I posted here before.
(Nicolay-1 was not drilled on the anticline shown on the graphic. They moved it away/left from the anticline after this graphic was made)
NSE Price at posting:
39.0¢ Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held