contradictory in awc evaluation

It has been always difficult for me to understand evaluation of stocks by “prominent” stock brokers.

Here is a very simple example proving this point:

- In a recent Huntleys’ money weekly issue (4 April 2013) this stock has a buy recommendation and a valuation of $2.85

- At the same time a Commsec Research report of 12 April 2013 values the stock as underweight with a 12 month target of $0.75.

So as you can see their evaluation differs by almost 4 times!!! This is unbelievable.

irynka