makattack, try using the actual forecasted figures generated after the Telstra deal and ACCC approvals were completed, instead of obsolete long range figures that have no relevance.
Glug I admire your incessant need to support Labor no matter what the facts are and evidenced by your 12 posts in this thread already, but the raw fact is, NBNCo have changed their forecasts so many times, that it's a joke to sit there and say, wow look at that they met their forecast. In 2010 NBN Co projected revenues of $160mill, but after many, many revenue downgrades, they've ended up with just $17mill...lol...of that's defensible then I suggest you become a defence lawyer, you'll make a fortune.
NBNCo could never have made money under the original plan. The uptake the plan relied on was never achievable. We need to see what coalition come up with after the review. I personally think the whole NBN project will be dismantled and re-born using a realistic plan.