I hope I am wrong as you can see it is an old article
Going, going, Gunns
By Tony Reardon - September 28, 2012
Yesterday, Gunns (ASX: GNS) notified the ASX that its lenders had withdrawn their support and the company could no longer continue trading so it has appointed PPB Advisory as the voluntary administrator.
The collapse of any company impacts a range of people including employees, suppliers, creditors, and, of course, investors. Given the swag of hybrid investments recently offered by companies such as Bendigo & Adelaide (ASX: BEN), Crown (ASX: CWN), and Suncorp (ASX: SBK) among others that some Foolish investors might be considering, it is perhaps sobering to review what happened to investors in the Gunns’ hybrids (ASX: GNSPA).
Gunns issued $120 million worth of hybrids back in 2005 with a face value of $100 that paid floating interest at the bank swap rate plus a margin of 2.5%, which is a similar arrangement to many of the current hybrid issues. In October 2008, these were to be redeemed for cash, converted into ordinary shares or the margin would “step-up” to 5%, which is what actually happened.
By early 2009, as the global financial crisis hit, the hybrid share price had halved, which meant that the effective interest rate that investors received soared to around 18% per annum. The company apparently had assets that more than covered all its debts, so there was a possibility of a 100% capital gain if and when the hybrid was redeemed. Distributions continued without interruption through until April this year even though trading in both the hybrid and the ordinary shares was suspended in March.
In August the company announced it was converting the hybrids to ordinary shares, removing any hope that hybrid holders would rank as creditors — they were, and always had been, equity investors. To rub salt into the wound, a clause in the issue documentation limited the maximum number of shares to 421.7 per hybrid, which, at the last market price, was about $67 worth.
It’s a bit irrelevant as to how many shares a hybrid holder gets if they are worthless as seems likely, but there is a final twist. The actual conversion doesn’t happen until the 15th October and the company is now in administration, so can it legally issue another 500 million shares. Does this make any difference to the outcome for hybrid holders?
Foolish takeaway
High interest rates equals high risk, and no amount of interest compensates for the loss of 100% of capital. Hybrids have bond-like returns but equity-style risks. If you choose to invest in any hybrid, make sure you understand the terms and condition,s as they are all different and most of them heavily favour the issuing company — not the individual investor
GNS Price at posting:
0.0¢ Sentiment: None Disclosure: Held
