What do you make of Amaysim response?, page-25

It's down because:

• they made revs of 117.3m vs macquarie at 128.4m (9% miss)
• EBITDA of 12.6m vs Macq at 16m (21% miss).
• They've 'reaffirmed' prospectus guidance of $31.7m EBITDA in FY16 - even despite having acquired Vaya, which was supposed to be earnings accretive!

combine that with the fact they gave a 'not aware' so recently, and not only do you have a terrible result but you've got a trust deficit.

Onto the naughty list with AYS, tut, tut!