Interview with Gary on the 05/07/17
Will you pay for data and content or rely on sponsored content? (interview)
The big debate now is whether content should be free, sometimes supported by advertising like Free-To-Air TV and iTWire’s own internet news service, and sometimes by subscription – like Foxtel. But there are other ways too.
More and more we are seeing paywalls erected, ad-blockers, and internet and OTT (Over-the-top) services seeking payment to cover costs and maybe make a profit. The fact is that every business in the world needs to make money or die.
ITWIRE spoke to Gary Greenbaum, CEO and Co-Founder of
Syntonic, a Seattle-based mobile technology company that has developed two services: Freeway by Syntonic, which provides sponsored data, data rewards, and data-free OTT content services on the mobile internet; and Syntonic DataFlex, which enables businesses to manage mobile split billing expenses for employees when using their personal mobile phones for work.
The question was broad – what are the new access models for monetizing the mobile internet for emerging and developed markets.
What problem is Syntonic trying to solve?
Syntonic was founded four years ago on the conviction that the mobile data plan is an arcane concept that is limiting the mobile ecosystem from capturing the full business opportunity of the internet.
Four years later it’s become clear that data plans are an awkward and increasingly irrelevant hold-out from the days when phones were principally communications devices that needed some metering-based revenue model to accommodate the new experience afforded by WAP browsers.
Mobile data is following the same commodity pattern as voice and text. One carrier’s data is no different than another’s, and the ensuing price wars are jeopardising the viability and deployment plans of next generation networks.
Over the last ten years, the smartphone has transformed from a strict communications device to becoming the world’s consumer gateway to information, entertainment, community, and knowledge.
Consequently, the real value in the mobile ecosystem shifted from the network operators to the service providers---from bytes of data to content and applications. What consumers value today is not commodity data, but the experiences associated with mobile access.
Syntonic’s vision is to transform the mobile access currency from today’s abstract “bits and bytes” to a currency of content and applications.
Several new access models emerge with this transformation that replaces today’s data plan model. One example is “content plans” - bundles of programming, pay-per-view, ad-based content delivery, etc.
Sponsored data is part of this new access model, and allows brands and app publishers to reach and engage consumers by paying for their mobile internet access. Sponsored data is a benefit for consumers receiving free access to content over the internet. These content-driven, consumer-friendly business models reinvigorate today’s declining mobile carrier ARPU, average revenue per user and provide a new revenue stream for growing subscriber ARPU.
Why is NOW the right time for a new mobile access model?
For the first time in the history of the mobile industry, we are witnessing declining carrier ARPUs (average revenue per user).
In developed markets, where market penetration for mobile access is high, data has become a commodity with price as the only means of differentiation.
In emerging markets, where mobile access is still far from market saturation, the opposite problem surfaces: access pricing has resulted in limiting both the sheer number of consumers who can access the mobile internet and how much they can access. As a result, carriers and brands are unable to monetize those disconnected or infrequently connected consumers.
To put this into context, more than 2.0 billion people ration their data use, especially in Africa, Asia-Pac, and Latin America. In post-paid markets such as the United States, consumers also regulate their consumption of mobile content, such as video and audio, in fear of exceeding their data plans. According to a CTIA study, 67% of US consumers would choose a service if it offered content that didn’t count against their monthly data allowance (2014).
Fortunately, there are proven alternative monetization models, such as those from the cable business and from over-the-air broadcast where subscriptions, pay-per-view, and ad-supported programming are offered. Cable operators don’t meter data: these fixed-line operators are principally in the content aggregation business selling both advertising and content subscription packages.
Syntonic’s platform enables carriers to quickly make the transition from commodity network operators to premium content service providers.
As in traditional broadcasting, access can now be sponsored by brands---reducing the frictions for end-users to consume high-data consumptive media offerings. However, the unique proposition is how content providers and app developers can advance engagement and retention with customers using promotional data-free access to their on-line assets.
Sponsored data provides this cost-efficient tool as marketing dollars are only spent on engaged customers, an audience far closer to monetization than can be achieved through CPI or CPM spending. Brands and content providers don’t need to allocate new marketing funds for sponsored data---rather they can reallocate their existing budgets to leverage the great cost efficiencies associated with sponsored data for acquiring and engaging with consumers.
The commoditization of mobile data is occurring while we’re witnessing unprecedented worldwide consumer demand for mobile content. This has put pressure on mobile operators to change their business models from data plans to content plans, For the first time, mobile operators are seeing a flattening or declining revenue across their subscribers. It’s a losing proposition for mobile operators to simply compete on price for a commodity that consumers don’t even understand. Fortunately, consumers do understand and value apps and content. Freeway by Syntonic enables sponsored data, data rewards, micro-plans, subscription services, and other content business models to help mobile operators transform themselves from undifferentiated data services to content services. Since it’s a multi-sided market Freeway by Syntonic is also helping app developers find more efficient ways to reach, acquire, engage, and monetize billions of consumers using these new models where mobile access is integral to the content. Mobile operators, content providers, and consumers all benefit from Freeway by Syntonic.
What are the changes you expect to occur in the mobile industry?
Sponsored data will transition from early adoption to mainstream deployment with mobile operators worldwide. More mobile carriers around the globe will partner with content providers to capture the enormous untapped prepaid market of nearly 2 billion mobile subscribers.
There is yet another exciting opportunity that arises for content providers when content is the access currency: OTT mobile video content services that are ad or subscription based. The scenario is that a large content publisher bundles data access with their content offering and monetizes that offering with end-user subscription or ads. This allows consumers to access video content, from premium entertainment to short-form music videos, that doesn’t impact their mobile data usage.
In the enterprise, BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) programs will continue to gain momentum, as companies encourage employees to work on their personal smartphone, and the work landscape increasingly relies on mobile devices for conducting business operations.
Currently, only about 60% of companies acknowledge having a formal BYOD policy (Gartner, 2013). Reimbursement will be the catalyst for establishing a formal policy, as more employees demand compensation when using their personal mobile phones for work.
In the U.S., mobile device split billing solutions will be a driving force accelerating the adoption of formal workplace BYOD programs (IDC, 2015). The key proposition is that smartphones on average raise employee productivity by 6.7 hours per week, but the benefits are being compromised by more than US$2.6 billion in annual overspend on BYOD reimbursements (Intel, 2013).
Businesses around the world are under pressure to compensate employees who use their personal smartphones for work. Personal smartphones are now integral to business operations and have resulted in an enormous boost in worker productivity. Until now businesses have had to guess at compensation or pay a stipend, which average USD$70 per month.
Syntonic DataFlex separates business use from personal use, enabling accurate compensation, saving businesses over 50% of their current spend, and it provides analytics that have the added benefit of helping businesses understand how mobile apps are being used within the enterprise. Syntonic’s Connected Services Platform – the same commercial engine that powers Freeway by Syntonic – is used by Syntonic DataFlex to provide split billing and analytics. Mobile operators that embrace Freeway benefit by opening up additional revenue streams to sell split billing services to the enterprise.”
Syntonic’s platform seems aligned to your vision of the future of mobility, but why don’t the carriers themselves create the same platform and solutions?
Mobile carriers have attempted to build their own content services platform. However, they have all fallen short of a complete solution, primarily because the carrier’s network-centric approach doesn’t mesh with the requirements for content services. The market pressure for carriers to compete with a comprehensive carrier-grade solution makes sponsored data the first and natural choice for mobile carriers.
The mobile access model is changing, and we see early carrier alignment with and investment in content around the globe. In the developed markets, this is a race to avoid commoditization; while in emerging markets, this is about monetizing the limited connected and unconnected.
Our bet is that those carriers that invest now in making this transition from network providers to service providers will survive the next wave of mobile innovation.
