I believe the fair value of Vita group lies around 240-260m based on following rationales.
Including FY18 and going forward EBITDA should be 40m plus.
FY20 may see bit of a blip, but depending upon performance of clean complexions, portfolio optimisation, new iphone releases, 5G performance there are good chances that EBITDA will be 40m plus.
So I am factoring 40m is base case EBITDA, I believe most of all the downsides are already factored in and there won’t be much of a nasty surprises going forward.
In FY16 EBITDA per store was ~$400,000, FY17 EBITDA per store increased to ~500,000, FY18 will be reduced to ~300,000 EBITDA per store.
In FY18 Vita bought total of 9 Telstra stores, 3 stores were purchased on 1st Dec 2017, which are expected to generate EBITDA of 1.2m per year and company paid around $2.5m for that. If one looks at the purchase history, generally Vita pays around 2 times EBITDA. They bought another 6 stores at the end of Feb 18 for $9.5m. They haven’t advised the EBITDA projection for these stores but assuming they would have paid twice the EBITDA then, these six stores will be generating around $4.7m EBITDA per year. So in total 9 stores will be generating around $6.0 EBITDA. That’s around $650,000 per store. So in that front company is investing and optimizing portfolio wisely to increase EBITDA per store. (They can still buy another 8 stores as per the contract)
Regarding Clear Complexions and Artisan Cosmetic & Rejuvenation Clinic purchases, theses 7 stores will be making EBITDA of $200,000 per store (~1.5m in total), If we look at the competitors regarding these segment, Laser clinic (Bought by KKR) makes around $500,000 EBITDA per store, and Clearskincare (which API bought in June) makes around $300,000 EBITDA per store.
So challenge lies with VITA to increase the EBITDA to a minimum level of $300,000, which I think Maxine can do.
Assuming minimum EBITDA of $300,000 per store including NIMA segment total EBITDA comes to $40.5m (135 X $300,000). Based on this EV should be around $240m, that’s $1.50 per share.
At SP of $1 VITA is trading at EV of ~140m ($160 -20m cash + 0 debt) that’s 3.5 EV/EBITDA, so clearly it is undervalued by 33%.
(These figures do not include further store increases in future for ICT or NIMA segments. Any further increase in number of store will add to baseline EBITDA of $40.)
That’s my rationale, happy to discuss it further.
Cheers
Expand