photo, page-48

"a man sits looking at a photograph and says ' Brothers and sisters i have none ,but that mans father is my fathers son' WHO IS IN THE PHOTO ? "

1. "a man sits looking at a photograph and says ' Brothers and sisters i have none ,but that mans father is ( my fathers son )' WHO IS IN THE PHOTO ? "

my fathers son => can be me or male siblings;

However, "Brothers and sisters i have none" means I do not have any siblings;

Therefore:

my fathers son => must be me;

Therefore replacing "( my fathers son )" with "me" gives:

2. A man sits looking at a photograph and says "Brothers and sisters i have none ,but that mans father is ( "me" )' WHO IS IN THE PHOTO ? ";

The statement "Brothers and sisters i have none" is now redundant. Therefore 2 becomes:

3. A man sits looking at a photograph and says "that mans father is me' WHO IS IN THE PHOTO ? ";

Therefore, must be his son.

SP