I think you are misunderstanding the intention of this thread.
It simply provides for a split in the charting/TA topic so that those who want to post a 1-minute chart every 4 minutes and discuss the very short-term trading opportunities/action can do so without drowning out the mid-long term charting/TA discussion and info.
I see it as a type of "day-trader" GXY thread, without heading off to the day trading forum. Imo it by no means insults or discredits the short-term TA we have seen of late, which it appears many indeed appreciate.
If anything, it expands the charting/TA topic here, which is great for those interested in the various details.
Just imo!
GXY Price at posting:
$3.87 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held