Ann: Funds Under Management - September 2022, page-72

First 72 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
LePok

210 Posts.

29

07/10/22

20:16

Post #: 64092482
Share

Originally posted by SaltyInvestor: ↑

Not as poor as the Magellan trade it seems @Jack1960

1) I have reviewed the posts and been on the MFG thread overall for several years, maybe you should try actually reading them carefully yourself. The holders and non-holders here are smart enough to understand Magellan is in a net-cash position. No-one who is engaged in markets has questioned its viability in the context of being an ongoing financial concern. Those who are are probably novice retail investors who have never seen this happen to them, but that has been very rare.

To even think that is beyond preposterous given many funds management companies are run by often by 1-2 decision makers and they survive despite underperformance, so why wouldn't Magellan? These are capital light businesses after all.

What you've done is used the "Trump play" - you've created the illusion that other people have said something in order to - pardon the pun - Jack yourself up, when that's not the case at all.

What IS the case is that there is a genuine concern is that this business is unviable as a value-turnaround candidate. If a funds management business keeps losing FUM and keeps underperforming the index, on what basis will its stock price do anything else but keep going down? Not into bankruptcy obviously, but into perpetual underperformance.

2) So on what basis is 2023 going to be a "nightmare" year for index investors? In the context of ETF investing, aside from inverse/leveraged ETFs, a nightmare can generally only occur based on the performance of an underlying asset. So unless you have a view that every asset class is going to crash, and Magellan will somehow outperform, then I'm perplexed.

By the way, let's not forget, what does Magellan offer? ETFs. Right? Between MGOC MICH and AASF, more than $15bn is sitting in Magellan's ETFs.

2023 will be a nightmare year indeed. For Magellan.

Expand

Magellan does Not offer ETF'S
when ppeople refer to ETF'S they are thinking of index trackers

Magellan offers listed version of actively managed funds

MFG Price at posting: $10.67 Sentiment: None Disclosure: Not Held
Upvote

0 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

KSN

Mineral Hill transition kicks off for Kingston, gold and silver ramp up to follow

Super PITch gold sponsor RSM Australia: Can Diggers & Dealers 2024 be key to reinvigorating IPO activity?

AIZ

Air New Zealand ditches 2030 emissions targets – right as ASIC's Scope 3 reporting changes kick in for FY25

MTL

Mantle Minerals' Nick Poll talks to HotCopper on finding gold grades up to 3.57g/t at Mt Berghaus

NWH

NRW Holdings voted Wealth Within's hot stock tip

There are more pages in this discussion • 134 more messages in this thread...

First 72 Last

Add MFG (ASX) to my watchlist

(20min delay)
Last $9.92		Change 0.070(0.71%)		Mkt cap ! $1.793B

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
$9.81	$9.96	$9.74	$4.954M	500.8K

Buyers (Bids)

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	251	$9.91

Sellers (Offers)

Price($)	Vol.	No.
$9.92	1304	2

View Market Depth

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	251	9.910
1	5000	9.890
2	2000	9.880
2	2309	9.870
3	8465	9.860

Price($)	Vol.	No.
9.920	1304	2
9.940	3414	3
9.950	3655	4
9.960	2276	3
9.970	1125	2

Last trade - 16.10pm 30/07/2024 (20 minute delay)

MFG (ASX) Chart

Ann: Funds Under Management - September 2022, page-72

Mineral Hill transition kicks off for Kingston, gold and silver ramp up to follow

Super PITch gold sponsor RSM Australia: Can Diggers & Dealers 2024 be key to reinvigorating IPO activity?

Air New Zealand ditches 2030 emissions targets – right as ASIC's Scope 3 reporting changes kick in for FY25

Mantle Minerals' Nick Poll talks to HotCopper on finding gold grades up to 3.57g/t at Mt Berghaus

NRW Holdings voted Wealth Within's hot stock tip

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

Ann: Funds Under Management - September 2022, page-72

Top Stories

Mineral Hill transition kicks off for Kingston, gold and silver ramp up to follow

Super PITch gold sponsor RSM Australia: Can Diggers & Dealers 2024 be key to reinvigorating IPO activity?

Air New Zealand ditches 2030 emissions targets – right as ASIC's Scope 3 reporting changes kick in for FY25

Mantle Minerals' Nick Poll talks to HotCopper on finding gold grades up to 3.57g/t at Mt Berghaus

NRW Holdings voted Wealth Within's hot stock tip

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News