WEEBIT NANO LTD (ASX:WBT) - Weebit - 2023 and beyond, page-224 - HotCopper | ASX Share Prices, Stock Market & Share Trading Forum

Originally posted by Surfguy: ↑

Love your enthusiasm and looks like plenty love those figures.
They may be a tad out though and we don't need confusion as many new investors come aboard.
That Yole report is problematic IMO.
As a student of Toni Seba I take these research analysts report with a large does of scepticism. These people use linear projections when disruption is clearly exponential.
To emphasise my point they predict MRAM to increase at the same rate as ReRam keeping its market share from 2024- 2027. That is a crock as it adds 20-40% cost to wafers to ReRam's 5-6% and its security re hacking is poor. MRAM is no chance in 2027.
Worse is the $3bill total market. The Flash NVM market size was $60bill last yr with NOR 25% of that. It is the fastest growing segment so by 2027 the predictions are for >$100bill overall Flash NVM.
The low hanging fruit WBT is targeting, NOR, @ 25% minimum of that so $25bill. This is a disruption and a tech one at that so will be fast. By 2027 anyone producing NOR flash is going broke.
By 2027 WBT should be attacking NAND flash with its discrete NVM ReRam.
Given this I prefer to ignore the Yole Report in favour of disruption so $25-30bill in 2027 I believe is closer to the mark. I also don't see anyone but TSMC and WBT in this disruption. First to market in disruptions usually wins the lions share. Let's say its 40% TSMC and WBT each to allow for others.
WBT may also be produced by TSMC so we may end up well over 50% share. Let's call that $10 to $15bill as market share for WBT.
Our revenue model though is royalties which is were you have made a mistake. Yole $1bill revenue by 2027 will not be all going to WBT and of the estimated $400mill(40%) revenue WBT's share is approx 2.5%. That is just $10mill @ pe50 is only $500mill MCap.
At total disruption of MRAM Yole report means $3bill total revenue, so its 3x the $500mill MCap or $1.5 bill. Pick your preferred PE ratio to go up or down from here. Not so good now is it.
However if total disruption of NOR flash happens around 2027 and the market is far bigger for ReRAM than predicted lets go 50% share of $30bill so $15bill at 2.5% is $375mill at a PE of 30 being conservative gives a MCap of $11bill. Now that's more like it.
New Investors this is a disruption and a super disruption at that IMO. Flash NVM has no chance of surviving. If you want to learn about disruption and exponential growth search out Toni Seba at ReThink X. You will learn so damn much and when you study it you start to see disruption everywhere. You will also never trust a research analysts report ever again because they all extrapolate linearly not exponentially.
Hope this helps and please do the numbers as I could be out. Last Sept's Gilder report on WBT website under the Invertor tab and Analyst's Reports has all this info and is one of the best reads on WBT.

Expand

“WBT may also be produced by TSMC so we may end up well over 50% share. Let's call that $10 to $15bill as market share for WBT.Our revenue model though is royalties which is were you have made a mistake. Yole $1bill revenue by 2027 will not be all going to WBT and of the estimated $400mill(40%) revenue WBT's share is approx 2.5%. That is just $10mill @ pe50 is only $500mill MCap.”

How are you calculating royalties? I thought royalties were calculated as a percentage of gross wafer sales. That is between 1.5 to 3% of gross wafer sales. Of course there are various revenue opportunities but percentage of gross wafer sales I thought was around these figures depending on the node/fab deal negotiated.

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	501	$2.30

No.

Vol.

Price($)

501

$2.30

Price($)	Vol.	No.
$2.31	14000	1

Price($)

Vol.

No.

$2.31

14000

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	501	2.300
10	51579	2.290
7	35187	2.280
7	35012	2.270
6	72346	2.260

No.

Vol.

Price($)

501

2.300

51579

2.290

35187

2.280

35012

2.270

72346

2.260

Price($)	Vol.	No.
2.310	14000	1
2.320	36065	3
2.330	28874	6
2.350	33198	3
2.360	5731	2

Price($)

Vol.

No.

2.310

14000

2.320

36065

2.330

28874

2.350

33198

2.360

5731

(20min delay)
Last $2.30		Change -0.010(0.43%)		Mkt cap ! $434.5M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
$2.33	$2.34	$2.30	$1.096M	476.0K

Weebit - 2023 and beyond, page-224

Brine and shine: Arizona Lithium wins early stage eco approval to commence wellpad #2 at Prairie

Invictus banks US$5M from Zimbabwean investment fund in support of Cabora Bassa

Biome unveils three year revenue target up to $85M – but are 3Y targets enough to excite?

PAM secures high-grade Chilean copper play in strong territory

$550 million Jabiluka uranium offer comes unstuck as Government rules lease won't be renewed

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

Weebit - 2023 and beyond, page-224

Top Stories

Brine and shine: Arizona Lithium wins early stage eco approval to commence wellpad #2 at Prairie

Invictus banks US$5M from Zimbabwean investment fund in support of Cabora Bassa

Biome unveils three year revenue target up to $85M – but are 3Y targets enough to excite?

PAM secures high-grade Chilean copper play in strong territory

$550 million Jabiluka uranium offer comes unstuck as Government rules lease won't be renewed

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News