Australia's largest stock trading and investment forum Australia's #1 stock forum

The right to respond, page-2

First 2 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
gumUnderfoot

26,791 Posts.

180

01/08/24

14:42

Post #: 75028287
Share

Originally posted by bacci: ↑

When a country is attacked does it have the right to respond? Is responding to the aggressor with consequences a moral imperative?
Alternatively should it "turn the other cheek" so as to avoid "escalating " the situation?

Lets look at history.

When Germany invaded Poland the UK issued an ultimate for Germany to withdraw, the didn't and the UK declared the start of WW2.
When Japan bombed Pearl Harbour the US declared war.
Both of these retaliations resulted in millions of deaths, should the UK and USA have "turned the other cheek".

When Osama Bin Laden co ordinated an attack on the USA the USA, Australia,Canada, UK etc invaded Afghanistan to kill Osama. Was that justified?

Hamas attacked Israelis and took hostages, is retaliation justified?

In my opinion in all these examples it was best to retaliate, otherwise aggression will increase and the world would be worse off.

bacci

Expand

It's just some weird deception where the inhabitants of this tiny speck of dust in the cosmos that spins around itself and around the sun, can't get along.
They have all this stuff going on in their heads thinking they know something about something.
2 Upvote

Reply

Top Stories

PSC

Prospect's Mumbezhi Project puts it at the middle of copper's megatrend. And FQM just bought in

STN

Saturn brings up seventh straight Apollo Hill upgrade on 'impressive' 300-hole drill run

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 018 – Potatoes, TACOs, and the $120M helicopter heist

AII

A new NASDAQ listing for a key player in the global critical minerals space

SYR

Syrah jumps +19% as graphite tariff threat spurs optimism down under

Week 29 Wrap: ASX hits new all time high of 8,766pts ahead of Aug 1

BDM

Burgundy plunges -20% after turning to layoffs to navigate record-low diamond prices

HotCopper Highlights: Trigg; Droneshield; Lumos & more

SER

Strategic Energy extends its QLD copper-gold frontier with Diamantina acquisition

DRO

History repeats for DroneShield investors but carnage so far subdued

First 2 Last