I've downloaded Etoro, CMC, and IG and trying a few paper trades...

I've downloaded Etoro, CMC, and IG and trying a few paper trades through each to get a feel.
IG has a nice interface but being stuck to contract size for indices is a bit restricting and I've heard of a few having issues like your reporting which must be frustrating. Glad they made it right for you but a bit of a turn off when looking for a new broker.