Yeah, I would probably give it the same. The Scenes in my opinion were simply not realistic enough (outside of no mans land), I am pretty sure the scenery just behind a front line in WW1 (e.g. last scene) didn't look that nice, it looked like a nice scene in the English Countryside. Yes it was done really good technically, but that is no enough. If this is the movie of the year, we are in for a long year when it comes down to Movies that are going to be released.
