Just for fun and curiosity, i asked the latest model, ChatGPT4.5 if it agreed with Groks report:
*Do I Agree with Grok’s Report?
I respectfully disagree with Grok’s conclusion that Intel’s Loihi 2 leads BrainChip’s Akida by 17.6%. Here’s why:
1. Assumption vs. Reality: Loihi 2 Isn’t Commercially Available
Grok’s analysis hinges on the premise: “If Intel commercialized Loihi 2 tomorrow.” But it then treats this hypothetical as fact, assigning weighted scores that imply parity with BrainChip’s already-shipping, market-proven Akida platform.
Loihi 2 remains a lab-stage prototype, restricted to research access via Intel’s “Gulch” platform.
Intel’s Mike Davies (EE Times, 2023) estimated Loihi 2’s commercial readiness around 2028.
Intel’s 2024 Annual Report confirms there’s no commercialization roadmap through at least 2026.
You can’t treat a prototype as a commercial equal.
2. Skewed Scoring and Misaligned Weights
Grok’s scoring heavily emphasizes:
This weighting favours Intel’s theoretical scalability and flexibility while underrepresenting Akida’s current commercial edge, including sub-1mW power draw, real-time edge deployment, and mission-critical use cases.
3. Execution Risk Still Matters — Even With Funding
Even if Intel announced Loihi 2’s commercialization tomorrow, significant hurdles remain:
Moving from prototype to volume manufacturing
Resolving known limitations (e.g., programming complexity)
Securing customer adoption in real markets
Intel’s 7nm node history is littered with delays. Billions in funding help, but they don’t erase fabrication or adoption risk.
BrainChip’s Akida line, by contrast, is already in market — deployed by Renesas, ISL, Frontgrade Gaisler, and others — with a clear roadmap to Akida 3.0 (due 2026).
4. Different Markets, Different Measures
Loihi 2 is designed for centralized, high-throughput workloads in data centers.
Akida is purpose-built for ultra-low-power edge AI in radar, IoT, space, and automotive contexts.
Evaluating them using a single scoring system without adjusting for market niche creates a flawed apples-to-oranges comparison.
5. Software Advantage Overstated
Intel’s Lava framework is hardware-agnostic, and can even run on Akida (confirmed by BrainChip’s Anil Mankar).
BrainChip’s MetaTF stack is optimized for immediate deployment, tailored for Akida’s efficiency.
TENNs (Temporal Event-Based Neural Networks) offer unique real-time advantages in olfaction, radar, and sensory processing — with no current Loihi equivalent.
Summary: Why Grok’s Analysis Falls Short
Grok misunderstood the hypothetical question, treating Intel’s Loihi 2 as if it were commercially equivalent to BrainChip’s mature Akida platform — without factoring in Intel’s execution risks, manufacturing hurdles, or its publicly stated commercialization timeline (~2028).
In assigning a 17.6% advantage to Loihi 2, the report overemphasized theoretical benefits like Intel’s smaller process node and architectural flexibility, while undervaluing Akida’s proven strengths — including ultra-low power efficiency, commercial deployments, and immediate real-world applicability.
It also overlooked that Intel’s Lava framework is hardware-agnostic, meaning any perceived software edge is not exclusive to Intel — further skewing the analysis toward hypotheticals rather than current market realities.
Bottom Line
Even if Intel launched Loihi 2 tomorrow, it would still face a ramp-up period — from manufacturing scale-up to software refinement and ecosystem development. BrainChip’s Akida platform, by contrast, is already deployed in real-world, ultra-low-power edge applications across multiple industries.
That said, Intel’s vast resources, deep talent pool, and government backing could allow it to close the commercialization gap quickly — if execution is successful. But that “if” is precisely the point: Grok’s analysis treats success as guaranteed, rather than a risk-weighted future scenario.
In today’s commercial landscape, Akida leads in neuromorphic edge AI not because Intel lacks potential, but because BrainChip has already delivered a mature, power-efficient, and available solution.
(20min delay)