Australia's largest stock trading and investment forum Australia's #1 stock forum

WSA

0.00%

$3.86 western areas limited

It looks like another GXY&ORE, APT&SQ merger

First 78 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
SnowballKelvin

276 Posts.

31

23/08/21

13:59

Post #: 55499447
Share

Originally posted by nuadrehc: ↑

Western Areas reports its full year results tomorrow (24th). IGO reports its full year results on the 31st August.

Given ASX disclosure requirements, if a deal is close, I think the absolutely earliest time they would announce it would be tomorrow. It doesn't make much sense for WSA to have to go into a trading halt right before they release their annual results. A lot of the major investment banks are advising either WSA (Goldmans + Rothschilds) or IGO (Macquarie). Also notice that BHP's advisors for the recent Woodside merger were JP Morgan, Barclays, and Goldmans. It means if these discussions are real then all of these banks are conflicted and can't write research (have you seen a Macquarie or Goldmans report on WSA or IGO in the last few weeks? I haven't).

We'll likely see all of the remaining analysts focus on this potential merger during WSA's Q&A session tomorrow, and Dan and Joe will have to fend off some direct lines of questioning.

The longer this speculation goes on the worse it is for IGO. As I've pointed out previously, the relative valuations for IGO and WSA are so lopsided, even at current share prices (e.g. IGO has a valuation that is 7x WSA's valuation yet it only generates ~6x the earnings).

If you think the merger happens then the clear carry trade for all of the institutions is either to short IGO and go long WSA or sell their IGO shares and buy WSA shares. Ignoring tax, if you sell your IGO shares and you use the proceeds to buy WSA shares you end up with IGO shares in the end anyway, just more IGO shares than you started with. This is why the WSA share price has been going up and IGO has been going down following the AFR leak. This is clearly bad for IGO's share price and it makes the deal economics look worse given, if they bid, it's mostly going to be in new IGO shares. The IGO/WSA share price ratio has already fallen from around 4x before the AFR leak (IGO 9.90/WSA 2.50) to around ~3x currently (IGO 9.20/WSA 3.10). So this forces IGO to accelerate discussions to either get to an agreement with a locked in exchange ratio, or they have to walk away quickly before their share price tanks any further. All of the bankers, lawyers, and advisors would know this.

I actually think the earliest time that any IGO/WSA deal gets announced is at the same time/after the IGO results. At that point both companies have then reported their full year results so this information is "cleansed" into the market. As a shareholder of both companies I think it's a very logical merger, but it needs to be done at the right price for WSA shareholders.

Expand

It looks like another GXY&ORE, APT&SQ merger

WSA Price at posting: $3.06 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held
3 Upvote

0 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

Week 34 Wrap: HotCopper's top watched; Oz banks cut saver interest; Kamala’s 28% corporate tax; AI’s back

CC9

Chariot locks in high-potential drill target at Black Mountain, one of the USA's largest lithium landholdings

SER

How flooding did Strategic Energy Resources a favour: Four holes down in 'redesigned' gold & copper campaign

The business of sport: Warren Tredrea's take on this week's news

The Rising Tide: How institutional adoption is shaping the future of crypto

There are more pages in this discussion • 22 more messages in this thread...

First 78 Last

Add WSA (ASX) to my watchlist

It looks like another GXY&ORE, APT&SQ merger

Top Stories

Week 34 Wrap: HotCopper's top watched; Oz banks cut saver interest; Kamala’s 28% corporate tax; AI’s back

Chariot locks in high-potential drill target at Black Mountain, one of the USA's largest lithium landholdings

How flooding did Strategic Energy Resources a favour: Four holes down in 'redesigned' gold & copper campaign

The business of sport: Warren Tredrea's take on this week's news

The Rising Tide: How institutional adoption is shaping the future of crypto

Featured News