So she got between 55-60% by 3 August and I was ridiculed for...

So she got between 55-60% by 3 August and I was ridiculed for predicting this based on assessment of other friendly takeovers and the fact FMG weren't selling. All those predicting around 30% were praised. People should make a distinction between what they wish for and opinion.

I predict Atlas will lose some port rights in the use it or lose it negotiations in September. FMG and Hancock will take up the slack. Then Hancock has got what it was after and will mothball loss making operations.

But do your own research and criticise mine. Waiting on my bank deposit, Hancock have been generous.