The absence of real-time data for covered short-selling in Australia can be attributed to how short-selling is regulated and reported under current laws. Here's a breakdown of why this data is not available in real time:
---
1. Regulatory Framework in Australia
Ban on Naked Short-Selling: The ban ensures all short-sellers have borrowed or located the shares before executing trades, reducing settlement risks.
Covered Short-Selling Allowed: While this practice is legal, it requires participants to report positions post-trade rather than pre-trade or in real time.
---
2. ASIC’s Short-Selling Reporting Mechanism
Delayed Reporting: ASIC mandates short-sellers to report their positions on a T+2 (trade date plus two days) basis. This means short-selling data is published with a delay, not in real time.
Daily Aggregated Reports: These reports show the total short interest for each stock but do not provide a breakdown of intraday activities or trade-by-trade details.
---
3. Practical Limitations of Real-Time Reporting
Complexity of Tracking Securities Lending: Covered short-selling involves borrowing shares through agreements, which are processed across multiple intermediaries. Real-time reporting would require significant system changes and coordination across brokers, clearinghouses, and regulators.
Market Stability Concerns: Real-time short-selling data could amplify market volatility, as investors might react impulsively to short positions rather than considering fundamentals.
Administrative Burden: Implementing real-time reporting would impose operational and cost challenges on brokers and financial institutions.
---
4. International Comparisons
United States: Short interest is reported bi-weekly by the SEC, with no real-time reporting requirement. Daily data on executed short sales is available but does not distinguish between new short positions and routine trades.
China: Short-selling is entirely banned, so no data exists.
Europe: Some countries provide more frequent updates, but real-time data is rare due to similar concerns about volatility and administrative feasibility.
---
Implications for BOE Retail Investors
Delayed Insights: Retail investors can only access short interest data with a delay, making it harder to interpret real-time market dynamics caused by short-selling activity.
Monitoring Alternatives: Use the daily ASIC short position reports (link) to track trends over time, even if not immediate.
---
Closing Thought
The lack of real-time data reflects a trade-off between market transparency and practicality. While real-time reporting could provide valuable insights for retail investors, the administrative and systemic challenges currently outweigh the benefits in Australia’s regulatory framework.
An AI-ASSISTED content
BOE Price at posting:
$2.76 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held
A personalised tool to help users track selected stocks. Delivering real-time notifications on price updates, announcements, and performance stats on each to help make informed investment decisions.
(20min delay)