I should add that I also heard (as others have stated above),...

First 550 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
aes411

1,634 Posts.

783

10/12/21

11:22

Post #: 58210122
Share

Originally posted by aes411: ↑

My notes:

Item 1: ASX seeking to strike off quotes ISX extracted from the ASX/ASIC meeting memos on the basis they were "evidence" and not "facts".

Both parties put forward their arguments over and over; I think both arguments were reasonable.

ASX's main argument was that the meeting memos were handwritten and not "official' transcripts and should not be included as facts in the pleading if ISX plans to rely on them as their evidence in the trial.

ISX argued that it wasn't just an internal ASX meeting; this was an important meeting between two regulators the day before the suspension and was said in the meeting is critical to understanding whether ASX acted in good faith or not, which is what the whole lawsuit is about. ISX also argued ASX needs to admit whether those things were said or not, in order for the case to progress faster.

Her Honour finally stated that at this juncture, each party should be clear on what the other party planned to rely on in their defence; it was clear to ASX that ISX was planning to rely on the meeting memos, but it was still unclear what ASX was planning to rely on. Irrespective of how these things are stated in the claims, at some point, ASX will have to admit if the memos could be taken as an accurate representation of what was said or not. So that was dismissed.
ISX also argued for some costs but I think that was dismissed as being insignificant (not too sure as I was distracted).

Item 2: Security of costs
Not much was said about this; ISX seemed to agree on the condition a date be changed from (I think) 4 March to 31 March. ASX didn't object.

Expand

I should add that I also heard (as others have stated above), ASX was put on notice; I'm not a legal expert so I'm not exactly sure what it means.

ISX Price at posting: $1.07 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held
18 Upvote

0 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

Has uranium run out of steam? An update on nuclear markets & developments ahead in FY25

SS1

Sun Silver to kick off drilling next week at 292Moz Maverick Springs silver-gold project

AHK

Ark Mines inks 1.5Bt Exploration Target for Sandy Mitchell REE play including NdPr; PFS due in Q4

SS1

Sun Silver gets that drill to thrill feeling from high grade hits at Maverick Spring

World Gold Council says market in want of catalyst; flags Asia sell-off risks. Then there's Trump

There are more pages in this discussion • 32 more messages in this thread...

First 550 Last

Add SP1 (ASX) to my watchlist

I should add that I also heard (as others have stated above),...

Top Stories

Has uranium run out of steam? An update on nuclear markets & developments ahead in FY25

Sun Silver to kick off drilling next week at 292Moz Maverick Springs silver-gold project

Ark Mines inks 1.5Bt Exploration Target for Sandy Mitchell REE play including NdPr; PFS due in Q4

Sun Silver gets that drill to thrill feeling from high grade hits at Maverick Spring

World Gold Council says market in want of catalyst; flags Asia sell-off risks. Then there's Trump

Featured News