Who is questioning Tom's management, who is saying Tom has...

Who is questioning Tom's management, who is saying Tom has managed badly?
Some Bold posters making bold statements.

On the other hand, I assert there are some undeniable factual information about the demise of the SP over time. The degree to which Tom is complicit or had other options open to conjecture.

If he's made deal of the year or simply the only deal which was available to him, I can't say, not having managed an oil company (if that's a prerequisite to comment), ....but I can say the market remains unconvinced being a shareholder.