Where do I start?

I don't have time to write them so got a good friend AI to list

Why P/E Is a Poor Statistic for Gold Mining Companies

Key Limitations of P/E for Gold Miners

• Cyclicality and Earnings Volatility: Gold mining companies’ earnings are highly sensitive to the commodity price cycle. During periods of high gold prices, earnings can be temporarily inflated, making P/E ratios appear artificially low. Conversely, when gold prices fall or costs rise, earnings may be depressed, causing P/E ratios to spike and potentially misrepresent a company’s true value2.

• Non-Recurring and Non-Cash Items: Mining companies’ earnings often include significant non-cash charges (e.g., asset write-downs, reclamation provisions) and one-off items that distort the true underlying profitability. This makes the "E" in P/E less reliable as a measure of ongoing earning power9.

• Difficulty in Earnings Forecasting: Gold miners face unpredictable operational disruptions, fluctuating grades, and volatile input costs. These factors make it difficult to forecast earnings accurately from quarter to quarter, further undermining the reliability of P/E as a valuation tool9.

• Resource Depletion and Reserve Uncertainty: Unlike many other industries, mining companies are constantly depleting their reserves, and the future value of their assets depends on their ability to replace those reserves economically. P/E fails to capture the risk and cost of finding and developing new resources2.

• Accounting Differences and Comparability: Differences in accounting policies, amortization methods, and reporting standards across companies and jurisdictions can make direct P/E comparisons misleading, even within the same sector27.

Better Metrics for Gold Miners

Given these issues, investors and analysts often prefer alternative valuation metrics for gold mining companies, such as:

• Price-to-Net Asset Value (P/NAV)

• Enterprise Value to EBITDA (EV/EBITDA)

• Price-to-Free Cash Flow (P/FCF)

• Enterprise Value per ounce of reserves/resources293

These metrics better account for the capital-intensive, cyclical, and asset-heavy nature of the mining industry, as well as the long-term sustainability of operations.

"Standard ratios like P/E (price-to-earnings) often prove misleading during different phases of the commodity cycle, while early-stage companies may lack the revenue and earnings required for such calculations entirely… This cyclical nature necessitates a more nuanced approach using metrics like Price-to-NAV, EV/EBITDA, and EV/Resource calculations adjusted for grade quality."