MP financials are in better shape than Lynas's in spite of their...

MP financials are in better shape than Lynas's in spite of their recent loss. If you think I am wrong show why with data. I already presented some. Weehawken I responded to your post Yet you seem to only be able to go back to MCP. there is not one person at MP even in middle management that was at MCP but that is what you used to discredit Current day MP. Apparently you cannot find anything to back up what you think in the two reports I gave you. If you could would you not have used it? Nick Curtis ran this company into bankruptcy and JARE would not bail them out till he was dismissed and AL took over. I would find it unfair if we judged AL on his performance yet you want to judge MP on MCP.

Just for record i like Lynas approach to Groth much better than MP's. Looking at prices Metals have poor margin over oxide and same is true of Magnets over Metals but this is path MP is choosing. i like Lynas approach of concentrate on Oxides much more. Unfortunately regardless of which approach is chosen the prices just are not high enough to support higher SP in the next 6 to 12 months. They may some time but I am not going to hold through a 25% to 50% SP drop in either one in the hope that this market might turn around in a year or two. I will sit it out and wait to see some proof that things will be better in the future.