Your argument does not make sense. Farmers around the world are...

First 241 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
prap

163 Posts.

38

13/02/24

10:48

Post #: 72376064
Share

Originally posted by piwi33: ↑

Which studies are they? Send me some and I will read them.

I follow alot of the H2 news and read alot of the studies. I've worked in H2 production and purification also. The people I follow are engineers and their concerns aren't with the cost of H2 production price. Most of the concerns aren't with H2 production price at all. They are with the physics of energy required to store and transport. Issues with the energy required to produce from electrolysers as well but a little less.

Having said that. If people have a genuine concern for emmissions and environment, they would surely be looking at the amount of renewable resources required to produce H2 at these massive scales. It's about 3x as much infrastructure and renewable producing assets than utilising the electrons as a priority. EG higher levels of electrification and battery storage.

So, if those building out renewable generation want to use 3x as many materials...sure, H2 works. But in the industrial world the same things always direct industries course. Cost and efficiency.

Safety is also a huge concern. You can say all of the right things and design to whatever you want, and ignore the cost of extra precautions and safety interventions. You cant ignore the physics of H2 safety. It is hard to handle and difficult to contain. It requires much more expensive materials and robust safety systems. Cost, cost, cost.

H2 has a massive use case industrially for alot of things. 100M tonnes currently. That's what I think should be the focus. Displacing SMR hydrogen just in that market alone accounts for massive reductions in emmissions, of which would be globally significant. Producing for transport is the absolute lowest value case for hydrogen. The fairytales being sold about it otherwise all invovle government money and subsidies. I havent seen otherwise and like I said, I am more than happy to be shown decent material that tells me otherwise.

Expand

Your argument does not make sense. Farmers around the world are subsidised by governments and are not viable on their own, this hasn't stopped them. Going to the moon was extremely dangerous too but this didn't stop them developing the technology to achieve this goal.

HZR Price at posting: 53.5¢ Sentiment: Hold Disclosure: Held
Upvote

0 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

HCH

Hot Chili sets up water company as drought racks Chile–but must also build communities a desal plant

RXM

Rex Minerals soars 60% on $390M Indonesian buyout deal from MACH Australia

PMT

High-grade lithium zone extended at Patriot's Corvette project, drilling grades at 5%

WCN

White Cliff gears up to explore expanded Nunavut Cu-Ag-Au project in Canada

CXO

Core Lithium narrowly beats guidance on FY24 spodumene production but 1Y returns still shattered

There are more pages in this discussion • 44 more messages in this thread...

First 241 Last

Add HZR (ASX) to my watchlist

(20min delay)
Last 36.8¢		Change -0.003(0.68%)		Mkt cap ! $84.56M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
37.0¢	37.0¢	36.0¢	$30.16K	82.18K

Buyers (Bids)

No.	Vol.	Price($)
3	3296	36.5¢

Sellers (Offers)

Price($)	Vol.	No.
37.0¢	35269	6

View Market Depth

No.	Vol.	Price($)
3	3296	0.365
8	75093	0.360
9	46204	0.355
12	71106	0.350
2	6420	0.340

Price($)	Vol.	No.
0.370	36284	8
0.375	52450	3
0.380	67508	4
0.385	61513	3
0.390	8884	2

Last trade - 13.25pm 08/07/2024 (20 minute delay)

HZR (ASX) Chart

Your argument does not make sense. Farmers around the world are...

Hot Chili sets up water company as drought racks Chile–but must also build communities a desal plant

Rex Minerals soars 60% on $390M Indonesian buyout deal from MACH Australia

High-grade lithium zone extended at Patriot's Corvette project, drilling grades at 5%

White Cliff gears up to explore expanded Nunavut Cu-Ag-Au project in Canada

Core Lithium narrowly beats guidance on FY24 spodumene production but 1Y returns still shattered

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

Your argument does not make sense. Farmers around the world are...

Top Stories

Hot Chili sets up water company as drought racks Chile–but must also build communities a desal plant

Rex Minerals soars 60% on $390M Indonesian buyout deal from MACH Australia

High-grade lithium zone extended at Patriot's Corvette project, drilling grades at 5%

White Cliff gears up to explore expanded Nunavut Cu-Ag-Au project in Canada

Core Lithium narrowly beats guidance on FY24 spodumene production but 1Y returns still shattered

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News