Well, from my point of view and ive said this 100s of times Iam all for open dialogue from other investors both Positive & Negative but the Cliche of it all is this person as a biased opinion and he's from the industry and his career promotes this material he's happy to give out an opinion whilst his background and career is in this field, but according to him previously he's just a person behind a screen with a lot of time on his hands, and it's just a hobby and he finds this industry interesting Lol. As the saying goes no one does anything for free, yet he's freely giving out his opinions like he's the cape crusader of HC.

I would also say being an Economist & Strategist & Geo which Coincides with cycles & markets as a whole this is also an advantage due to being in that industry, now if he truly believes that some MDs and boards need to be accountable with the material they submit to ASX they should be truthful and correct, well i 100 % agree with that thesis, but how does an investor like the majority here decipher what is right and what isn't, there's a lot of hypotheticals with his opinions then you have him coming out insinuating that people have no idea, don't shoot the messenger is his fav quote, yet for the most part we wouldn't of had have any idea who 2IC is because HC is an anonymous platform.



Anyway, i will add that Contrarian views are great and always will be providing there's no motive behind it!