MLM (ASX) Ann: Independent Expert confirms merger is Reasonable

Originally posted by melinvest: ↑

BDO is GUN SHY over FAIR and REASONABLE
Familiar players here ?

BDO facing legal action over mining reportBy Richard Baker & Nick Mckenzie22 January 2018 — 12:15am
Leading Australian accounting firm BDO is being sued over an allegedly “misleading and deceptive” independent expert report which supported a proposed merger of tin miner Kasbah Resources Limited with a Canadian-listed company.Kasbah lodged the writ against the Perth office of BDO Corporate Finance in the West Australian Supreme Court on December 18, claiming erroneous valuation statements used in the report wrongly advised shareholders that the proposed deal was “fair and reasonable” and in their best interest.Kasbah is a small ASX-listed company with its main tin asset in far-away Morocco and shares trading at 0.015 cents this week.It has had significant changes at board and executive level and has become increasingly tied to Russian oligarch Vladimir Iorich through his Swiss-based investment house, Pala Investments.The BDO errors were exposed in a separate report by rival firm Deloitte, which had been commissioned by a small group of rebel Kasbah shareholders who were wary of the proposed 2016 merger with Canadian-listed Asian Mineral Resources. Pala is a major shareholder in Asian Mineral Resources.BDO was forced to admit the mistakes and acknowledged that it should have told Kasbah shareholders that the proposed deal was “not fair, but reasonable” had the valuations been accurate.The discovery of the errors in the BDO report prompted the Federal Court in late 2016 to deny Kasbah’s application to push through its deal with Asian Mineral Resources.The Australian Securities and Investments Commission last year announced it would be increasing scrutiny of independent expert reports, which play a crucial role in advising boards and shareholders on the merits of takeover or merger offers.Last week ASIC announced the Melbourne arm of accounting firm HLB Mann Judd had volunteered to vary its financial services licence to exclude it from providing independent expert advice.The reason for HLB Mann Judd’s action and ASIC’s announcement of it remain unknown.Perth, meanwhile, is home to many small-cap mining companies, making it a lucrative place for accounting companies such as BDO to provide independent expert reports to boards.Last February, ASIC’s regional commissioner for WA, Jane Gouvernet joined the Perth office of BDO corporate advisory as an associate director.Ms Gouvernet has played no role in the Kasbah matter.The Kasbah writ names BDO Corporate Advisory WA partner and chairman, Sherif Andrawes, and fellow director Adam Myers as having prepared and reviewed the independent expert report.The writ accuses the pair of failing to meet the terms of BDO’s “Our Commitment to You” policy, which promises work of the highest quality.Kasbah paid BDO more than $50,000 to produce the independent expert report. It is seeking damages for breach of contract and costs.Mr Iorich’s Pala Investments was previously a target of the Australian government’s Project Wickenby investigation into tax evasion.The Australian Taxation Office accused Pala of avoiding $34 million in taxes associated with its shareholdings in Australian-listed companies. The ATO later dropped its Federal Court action after working with Pala to revise its initial tax assessments.A BDO spokesman said: "This matter is currently with our lawyers and we are unable to provide further comment."

Expand

From the "Experts" Report :

"After considering the information summarised above and set out in detail in the balance of this Report, it is our view that the Arrangement is Not Fair to Shareholders as at the date of this Report"

But the Board unanimously recommends it - wtf ???

Cheers - Surfydad

No.	Vol.	Price($)
2	537272	1.5¢

No.

Vol.

Price($)

537272

1.5¢

Price($)	Vol.	No.
1.7¢	87919	2

Price($)

Vol.

No.

1.7¢

87919

No.	Vol.	Price($)
2	537272	0.015
3	433874	0.014
1	50000	0.012
1	272815	0.011
2	250850	0.010

No.

Vol.

Price($)

537272

0.015

433874

0.014

50000

0.012

272815

0.011

250850

0.010

Price($)	Vol.	No.
0.017	87919	2
0.018	132313	1
0.019	300000	1
0.020	68500	2
0.021	206930	1

Price($)

Vol.

No.

0.017

87919

0.018

132313

0.019

300000

0.020

68500

0.021

206930

(20min delay)
Last 1.5¢		Change -0.001(6.25%)		Mkt cap ! $14.39M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
1.6¢	1.6¢	1.4¢	$44.84K	3.073M

From the "Experts" Report : "After considering the...

Frontier Energy achieves key milestone for Waroona energy project

Plagues precede widespread power shifts. We’re living in one – and minerals are at the fore

Shekel Brainweigh CEO Nir Leshem weighs in on AI adoption ahead of FY25

With financials holding the fort, materials must step up with some heavy lifting to stimulate stocks

If you thought lithium was dead, think again. The Pilbara will be central to the next upswing

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

From the "Experts" Report : "After considering the...

Top Stories

Frontier Energy achieves key milestone for Waroona energy project

Plagues precede widespread power shifts. We’re living in one – and minerals are at the fore

Shekel Brainweigh CEO Nir Leshem weighs in on AI adoption ahead of FY25

With financials holding the fort, materials must step up with some heavy lifting to stimulate stocks

If you thought lithium was dead, think again. The Pilbara will be central to the next upswing

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News