I thought Simongr's analysis was pretty fair and reasonable so I...

I thought Simongr's analysis was pretty fair and reasonable so I don't get your comment about it being a pure down ramping post.
If your not prepared to look at both the good and bad points on a stock its pointless looking at stock forums which are designed to show both sides of the story.
I personally am more than happy to see negative comments about a stock even if I hold it as long as the comments can be justified.
The more detailed analysis you do on a stock the more likely you are to get it right when deciding whether to buy/sell or hold it.