Ann: Q3 FY22 Quarter Update Conference Call Details /Presentation, page-48

I dont know if "RUBBISH" is entirely fair... that's just their opinion, and they may ultimately turn out to be "right" (but as always, you can be right presciently or flukily when claiming a compny might not make it).

The post you're replying to seemed balanced and respectful to me - "we" as a forum should encourage and welcome such contrary posts, which are important.

As it stands, DW8 is a great idea and management have an excellent plan (and I'm invested in it), but the poster you are quoting is right - unless and until it succeeds, it hasn't succeeded.