Ann: Response to Appendix 3Y Query, page-3

Yes, I agree they should have been getting runs on the board and the next 12 months looks good for them.
It's pretty painful seeing them get free options.

I just hope they're pressing in on the short side here and especially using options to get more juice, it's quite the bear market rally but looks like beatings for the "soft landing" crowd are due to resume until morale improves.

Not a fan of buybacks myself, I'd prefer them to support the shareprice by paying out the dividend rather than take advantage of shareholders who may sell if it was cut further. With the dividend you can always buy more PTM yourself or allocate it elsewhere.
I know that's a controversial take and we can agree to disagree.