atlantic multi decadal oscillation, page-9

"Go back one step: You asked for evidence which was in front of your nose. Having read it, you can't fault it, all you can do is ask more questions about details"

asking for details is faulting it.

Phillip_k posted a beautiful graph. But without even the most rudimentary fundamental information, like where it came from, where the data came from, how was the data collected, its meaningless.