Opportunities and insights for resources investors
MENU Why lithium price’s climb shouldn’t be a surprise
A commodities expert says its unclear what China can do to put the brakes on lithium prices with EV sales continuing to grow, after Pilbara Minerals set yet another record price for lithium raw materials (reports *).
29th September 2022
Share Article
Last week’s ninth auction on the Pilgangoora miner’s Battery Material Exchange bidding platform scored a haul of $US6988/t for a 5000t cargo of 5.5 per cent pure spodumene concentrate.
Given pricing is typically done on a 6 per cent Li2O (lithium oxide) benchmark, the actual take effectively was $US7708/t as the processor who bought the more than $50 million package will need to remove more waste.
That is processed into one of two general lithium chemicals for electric vehicle batteries, lithium hydroxide or lithium carbonate, both fetching more than $US70,000/t in the domestic market in China.
It’s an extraordinary outcome given PLS was selling contracted spodumene, the lithium rich concentrate produced at hard rock deposits in WA, for less than $US500/t this time in 2020, a mark of how quickly the EV sector has grown.
Clearly converters in China and elsewhere in South East Asia remain far more worried about securing supply than their material costs, with EV sales continuing to expand.
“The continuing escalations in prices for both lithium salts and spodumene are a clear reminder that we are still very much in the grips of a major supply shortage, which shows little sign of abating in the near-term,” Fastmarkets senior price development manager Peter Hannah told *.
Pilbara Minerals, which announced its first and record profit of almost $562 million for FY22 on the back of a surge in spodumene prices, has posted a new record in all but one of its nine BMX auctions so far.
Hannah is hardly shocked by the scale of this month’s escalation, which pounded like a pogo stick from August’s implied price of $US7,012/t.
“I don’t think we should be too surprised. These prices are merely a reflection of market conditions and what the marginal buyer is willing to pay,” he said.
“So long as there is still an incentive to produce EVs at these price levels there is no real reason for them to fall until we see a meaningful supply response.
“Demand destruction is a potential concern, but for the time being EV demand is still being driven by affluent early-adopters, and there are still long queues for most EV models.”
Fastmarkets currently says lithium carbonate is selling domestically on China’s spot market at a midpoint of 517,500 RMB and hydroxide for 515,000 RMB – about $US72,600/t and $US72,500/t respectively.
Above 500,000RMB per tonne Chinese authorities have tended to ring the bells on “stablilisation”, a bit of a code word for when the Communist Party thinks prices of commodities sold into the country from Australia, such as lithium and iron ore, are too damn high.
It is something which occurred again last week.
This is again unsurprising and something Hannah says it is unclear whether China will be able to get a handle on.
“I think China’s MIIT (Ministry of Industry and Information Technology) has something of a line in the sand at the 500,000 yuan per tonne level, as we’ve seen comments urging stabilisation whenever prices have touched that level,” he said.
“We are already through that level in the domestic market though, and what it can actually do to subdue prices is unclear.”
At prices like those seen in the Pilbara auction, converters are operating at very low margins, something under 5 per cent at current chemical prices according to Hannah.
It is worth noting most spodumene sells for less under long term contracts, no miner is 100 per cent exposed to spot – though some would like to be right now.
As noted it is an indication extreme market tightness, which some miners and analysts see remaining into the next decade, is still a major feature.
And each time spodumene prices lift, a call from Goldman Sachs of an imminent, supply-led, price collapse over the next 12 months looks more unrealistic.
The hammering local lithium stocks copped in the wake of Goldman’s wrecking ball report has given way to their biggest boom yet.
PLS, Allkem (ASX:AKE), Mineral Resources (ASX:MIN), IGO (ASX:IGO), and Core Lithium (ASX:CXO) are all at or near record highs, up 51.56 per cent, 37.43 per cent, 6.06 per cent and 13.11 per cent over the past six months.
More speculative stocks have found it tougher, but there are those who think risk capital is returning to the battery metals market.
They made up 15 of the 29 resources companies which completed IPOs on the ASX in the June quarter, up from 16 in the March quarter despite market jitters about interest rates, inflation and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
MinRes is said to be considering what would be a multi-billion spinout of its lithium business in the US, believing it is trading at a fraction of the multiples commanded by hot battery metals stocks on the NASDAQ, such as SQM and Albemarle.
CXO Price at posting:
$1.11 Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held
(20min delay)