climategate scientists cleared of manipulation, page-2

Butcherboy,
Good Headline "Cleared of Manipulation". However that selective headline is itself manipultion. It could just as easily have said "Guilty of Evasion and Misleading"
Note the quote below;

"Writing on Comment is Free, Dr Richard Horton, editor of the Lancet, who testified to the inquiry, said: "The Russell review has rejected all claims of serious scientific misconduct. But he does identify failures, evasions, misleading actions, unjustifiable delays, and pervasive unhelpfulness all of which amounts to severely sub-optimal academic practice. Climate science will never be the same again."

Bacci