You would be an absolute fool to trade CFD's with a market maker. Not much point comparing commissions if you intend on doing so. I've traded CFD's with MAN and IG Markets and been happy with both parties offering at market prices. You need to be aware of all commissions and charges so read the PDS closely. If you intend on trading very large positions and like to sleep easy at night then IG's guaranteed stops (which you will pay a premium for) are an attractive option. Good luck.
