EU tells BHP its Rio bid may break lawsOctober 23, 2008 -...

EU tells BHP its Rio bid may break laws
October 23, 2008 - 12:14PM


European Union regulators told lawyers for BHP Billiton Ltd. that its $US69 billion ($103 billion) hostile bid for London-based Rio Tinto Group may break antitrust rules, two people close to the case said.

The European Commission, the 27-nation European Union's antitrust regulator in Brussels, will likely issue the companies a so-called statement of objections, said the people, who declined to be identified because the regulator's proceedings aren't public. The objections will outline the commission's concerns that the combined company's share of the iron ore market may lead to price increases, the people said.

The decision may ratchet up the pressure on BHP to sell some assets and prove to regulators by Jan. 15 that the world's biggest mining merger won't restrain competition. Rio has traded at a discount of as much as 29% to the value of BHP's offer, indicating investors are betting the deal will fail.

``The EU is definitely the highest hurdle for BHP and the commission will seek to protect European steel mills,'' Damien Hackett, an analyst at Canaccord Adams Ltd. in London, said by telephone. ``I think BHP will end up with a list of asset divestments that they will find unpalatable.''

BHP may have to sell iron-ore or coal assets to get approval for the offer, ING Bank NV analyst Nick Hatch said last month. Global financial turmoil has scuppered other transactions, including Xstrata Plc's proposed 5 billion-pound ($12 billion) bid for platinum miner Lonmin Plc.

`Chances deteriorating'

``The financial crisis and governments having to rescue banks recently will give regulators a more negative view,'' Hackett said. ``The chances of BHP succeeding are deteriorating with the crisis, not getting better.''

Illtud Harri, a BHP spokesman in London, said the company will cooperate with the commission directly and won't comment on the process. Rio spokeswoman Christina Mills and Jonathan Todd, a commission spokesman, both declined to comment.

BHP this morning shed 10%, or $2.80, to $24.45 following a 7% drop yesterday and falls on overseas markets. Rio Tinto plummeted 15%, or $11.81, to $66.59.

The commission's statement of objections, which is a confidential document, will be sent as late as the first week of November, one person said.

BHP has the right to respond to the concerns and can ask for a hearing. Steelmakers, consumer groups and EU government representatives could attend the hearing and would have access to an edited version of the objections that has been stripped of confidential data.



Negotiations

The commission could use the objections as a basis to block the deal. Companies often overcome the concerns through negotiations with the commission on remedies to remove antitrust problems. In some cases, the regulator approves takeovers after sending objections and doesn't demand divestments or changes to the deal.

Earlier this year, the commission cleared TomTom NV's 2.9 billion-euro ($5.6 billion) acquisition of Tele Atlas NV without any changes to the terms of the deal after sending the companies a statement of objections in February. Australia raised concerns and then cleared BHP's bid without asking for divestments.

The commission stepped up its investigation in July after an initial five-week review, saying that it had ``serious doubts'' about a combination that would control more than a third of the world's iron-ore exports. BHP, already the world's biggest mining company, would also become the largest producer of copper, aluminum, and coal burned by power plants.

Sweetened offer

The commission restarted its review on Sept. 29 and will rule on the deal by Jan. 15. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and the US Department of Justice have approved the deal without seeking asset sales, while a decision is still pending in South Africa.

Rio, the world's second-largest iron-ore producer, rejected BHP's sweetened, all-share offer on Feb. 6, saying it undervalued the company and its growth prospects. BHP Chief Executive Officer Marius Kloppers, who's borrowing a record $US55 billion to pay for the deal, in February increased his offer to 3.4 shares for every one of Rio's, from a 3-for-1 proposal in November.

Asian and European steelmakers oppose the transaction, saying it would give BHP too much influence over iron-ore prices. The combined companies would vie with Brazil's Cia. Vale do Rio Doce as the world's largest supplier of the raw material used to make steel.

Price focus

The commission's probe has focused on iron-ore pricing, the people said. The EU regulator is concerned that prices would effectively be set by the combined company because of its large sales to China. The EU regulator is also worried about the impact on prices for coking coal, they said.

``The recent iron ore contract price negotiations illustrates what happens when big companies get together,'' Hackett said. BHP and Rio secured contract price increases of as much as 97% this year from steelmakers in China, the largest consumer.

The commission isn't likely to ask for asset sales in other areas, such as uranium, the people said.