you failed to refute anything i said because you know you can't....

you failed to refute anything i said because you know you can't. Government is not a business, they do not create revenue. They collect part of the revenue from other businesses. If those businesses do well the Government gets more. If there is a surplus it's because businesses have done well. In Australia's case that's mainly mining. We were on track for a surplus in 2020 because commodity prices started recovering in mid 2018 from years of bear market

The rest you wrote is just waffle. Climate change bla bla. Wont stop overseas nations from burning coal and using gas so if the Greens ever shut down our coal and gas sector it's because of their ideology and nothing to do with falling demand. But then say goodbye to future surpluses because we depend on those sectors even though greenie propaganda wants people to believe otherwise