RHK (ASX) FHS Shareholders and Todd Decision Tree

Originally posted by Huxleylock ↑

Firstly I am not a FMS shareholder, but I am a RTA shareholder hence have been reading the FMS posts with interest.

I am surprised at the voice against the Todd offer for FMS, but can understand the frustration that there is no clear path for funds to flow to shareholders unlike the RTA offer.

I wish I could load a picture but I can't - so I will try to outline my view of the deal in words. It involves plotting out the various decisions with respect to the option agreement, firstly by FMS shareholders and if a Yes vote is made then by Todd including flow of funds. Details taken from the announcement of the Todd option.

Decision 1. FMS Shareholders on Todd Option:
No - Project put into care and maintenance for 3-5 years, to develop it would require alternative transport route and new funding partner.
Yes - Receive $10m go to Decision 2.

Decision 2. Todd 31/12/16 Option Extension:
No - same outcome as Decision 1 No, but $10m better off
Yes - Receive $10m go to Decision 3.

Decision 3. Todd 31/12/18 Option Extension:
No - same outcome as Decision 1 No, but $20m better off
Yes - Receive $10m go to Decision 4.

Decision 4. Todd 31/12/20 No more option extension possible so Buy or Not:
No - same outcome as Decision 1 No, but $30m better off
Yes - Receive $55m go to Decision 5.

Decision 5. Todd, Develop project within 2 years of option exercise
No - FMS receives $20m plus potential royalty if and when developed
Yes - Royalty stream

Note Todd may exercise option to buy between a FMS s/h yes vote and 31/12/20, in which case they would effectively go straight to Decision 4 Yes and pay the $55m but could skip some of the $10m extension payments.

So what are the potential outcomes for a FMS S/H Yes vote:
1. Get it back in 1.5 years +$10m (I would say much better than No because $10m is received)
2. Get it back in 3.5 years +$20m (Still better than No)
3. Get it back in 5.5 years +$30m (Ok it is a long time, but $30m is a lot and if the Todd plan doesn't work in this time frame then I doubt a go it alone plan would either)
4. Option exercise and sit on it, FMS receives a minimum of $10m+$55m+$20m = $85m, potentially $20m more if the options are extended.
5. Option exercise and develop it, FMS receives a minimum of $65m + royalty stream

I feel 1-3 are better than No as FMS get to keep it + the money + all the DFS work done (what every that is, it is better than just care and maintenance), 4 and 5 is where FMS S/H need to get a commitment from management to payout special dividends or such like for FMS shareholders to benefit....

Expand

Well said , unfortunately there are some s/holders with very unrealistic expectations and want every thing to be their way . No one is going to invest millions of dollars into a project without getting a commercially viable return .
Todd in this case has a lot of work to do and money to tip in , not to mention the risk , if nothing comes of it , they've handed FMS $75 mil , FMS has what to do?
" there's the mine boys , start digging "

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	234	74.5¢

No.

Vol.

Price($)

234

74.5¢

Price($)	Vol.	No.
79.0¢	551	1

Price($)

Vol.

No.

79.0¢

551

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	234	0.745
3	6032	0.740
1	2075	0.730
1	10000	0.650
2	65000	0.530

No.

Vol.

Price($)

234

0.745

6032

0.740

2075

0.730

10000

0.650

65000

0.530

Price($)	Vol.	No.
0.790	551	1
0.800	4936	2
0.820	540	1
0.830	10355	1
0.870	3999	1

Price($)

Vol.

No.

0.790

551

0.800

4936

0.820

540

0.830

10355

0.870

3999

(20min delay)
Last 74.0¢		Change -0.005(0.67%)		Mkt cap ! $147.8M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
74.0¢	74.0¢	74.0¢	$239	323

FHS Shareholders and Todd Decision Tree, page-2

Revolutionary inverter technology leads the clean energy charge

Emerald & Azure score Digger & Dealer awards

Provaris tells ASX non-binding MOUs are still material to share prices in somewhat fiery compliance response

Exploring the causes and potential solutions to Australia's housing crisis

From the Floor with Federal Opposition Leader Peter Dutton at Diggers & Dealers 2024

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

FHS Shareholders and Todd Decision Tree, page-2

Top Stories

Revolutionary inverter technology leads the clean energy charge

Emerald & Azure score Digger & Dealer awards

Provaris tells ASX non-binding MOUs are still material to share prices in somewhat fiery compliance response

Exploring the causes and potential solutions to Australia's housing crisis

From the Floor with Federal Opposition Leader Peter Dutton at Diggers & Dealers 2024

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News