MPs’ ‘stunning’ property portfolios fuel crossbench calls for negative gearing changes
About two-thirds of federal parliamentarians own two or more properties, an analysis of the declared interests shows.
More than 65 per cent of all federal parliamentarians own two or more properties, drawing a stark contrast with the lived experience of millions of voters who rent as key crossbenchers and the Greens push the Albanese government to put negative gearing changes back on the agenda.
All MPs and senators must declare their property holdings in their register of interests, which is publicly available.
In the House of Representatives, where MPs must declare property owned by themselves or their spouses, 103 of 151 federal MPs own two or more properties, and 88 have declared having at least one investment property. Only a small number of MPs are renters.
In the Senate, where the rules do not require the disclosure of property in a spouse’s name, 47 of the 76 senators own two or more properties, while 30 have declared at least one investment property.
As the Coalition last week seized on Labor’s broken promise on the stage 3 cuts to mount a campaign warning the government would turn its focus to targeting tax concessions for property investors, the Greens and influential Senate crossbenchers David Pocock and Jacqui Lambie urged the government to revisit the issue in light of the housing affordability crisis.
Pocock said parliamentarians owned a “stunning amount of property compared to the average Australian” and called for a “sensible debate” about changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax discounts on investment properties.
“It’s hard to believe this doesn’t skew the perspective [of parliamentarians] when considering the suitability of generous tax concessions,” the independent ACT senator said.“I totally understand people wanting to invest in a property for their retirement, but I don’t think taxpayers should subsidise the purchase of a fourth or fifth investment property.”
Pocock owns a home in the ACT and has disclosed another property interstate for which he has lent friends money for their deposit and is on the title. His friends pay the mortgage, and Pocock does not derive income from the property.
Greens housing spokesman Max Chandler-Mather, who does not own property, labelled Anthony Albanese a “property investor prime minister” who was “refusing to phase out billions of dollars in property investor tax concessions that are denying millions of renters the chance to buy a home”.
“I’ve been a renter my entire adult life,” Chandler-Mather said.
“I know what it’s like to be evicted without grounds and cop an unfair rent increase, but it’s something that seems entirely alien to a Labor and Liberal Party stacked full of property investors who all oppose rent caps or changes to negative gearing.”
In the Labor caucus, 77 members of its combined total of combined total of 103 MPs and senators, or 75 per cent, have declared ownership of two or more properties in their names or their partners’ names. In the Coalition party room, this figure stands at 55 of its 86 MPs and senators, or 64 per cent.
The Greens have five members with two or more properties. Deputy leader Mehreen Faruqi and the party’s treasury spokesman Nick McKim both own four.
The prime minister owns two properties in Sydney’s inner west – his home in Marrickville and an investment property in Dulwich Hill – both of which are rented.
Opposition Leader Peter Dutton, who has cashed in the sizeable property portfolio he amassed with his wife in recent years, has declared owning just his residential farm in Dayboro, north of Brisbane.
Of those who did not declare a residential home on their interest register, six parliamentarians – less than 3 per cent of the parliament – confirmed to this masthead that they were renting. However, a number of these MPs and senators also held investment properties at the same time.
Those who were renting and owned no property include: Chandler-Mather and his Greens’ colleague Stephen Bates, and Liberal MP James Stevens. This compares with 30 per cent of Australians who are renters, according to the latest census data, while 35 per cent have a mortgage and 31 per cent own their homes outright.
While Dutton last week ruled out supporting any changes to negative gearing, the issue has been on the radar of other Liberals. In comments last week to a property summit, former NSW Liberal premier Dominic Perrottet called for negative gearing arrangements to be reviewed as part of broader tax reform saying “it could drive supply”.
Many economists, however, have argued that changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions alone would have a minimal impact on housing affordability, and instead boosting the supply of housing stock through less onerous planning laws and government investment was key.
“There are tax policy and equity arguments for changes to the negative gearing and the discount to the capital gains tax. However, it is a non-issue from the point of view of housing affordability,” said Dr Peter Tulip, a former Reserve Bank economist now at the centre-right think tank the Centre for Independent Studies.
Tulip pointed to multiple studies, including one by University of Melbourne academics published in the International Economic Review journal, which found that removing negative gearing would reduce house prices by 0.9 per cent and raise rents 2.5 per cent.
Another study, published in 2016 by the Grattan Institute which has backed policy reform to the concessions as budget-saving measures, found that abolishing negative gearing and halving the capital gains tax discount to 25 per cent would only lower house prices by about 2 per cent.
However, Grattan’s economic policy program director Brendan Coates said while the downward pressure on affordability would be “minuscule”, such changes would boost home ownership rates by making property investment less attractive.
“At the moment, some of those negatively geared investors are beating out first home buyers at auctions. That process changes if those tax concessions are wound back,” he said.
Coates said that the biggest impediment to reform in this area was not politicians being unprepared to act against their personal interests, but fears that they would be punished at the ballot box.
The cost of negative gearing to the budget was $2.7 billion in 2020-21 financial year. Negative gearing is the process whereby taxpayers lose money on investment properties which they then use to reduce their overall taxable incomes.
Labor went to 2016 and 2019 elections promising to restrict negative gearing to new properties only and to halve the 50 per cent capital gains tax deduction, with its tax agenda widely attributed as a key factor in Bill Shorten’s defeat in 2019.
Albanese abandoned the policies ahead of the 2022 election, and he and Treasurer Jim Chalmers have since repeatedly insisted there are no plans to revive them. But the prime minister did not categorically rule out future changes to negative gearing when challenged by the opposition in question time and in media interviews last week.
Instead, Albanese expressed support for the current settings and sought to redirect the focus to the government’s revamped stage 3 tax cuts when pressed on whether he would be prepared to negotiate with the Greens on the property tax concessions.
“What we’re focused on, and the Greens seem to want to talk about anything but, is the tax cuts that we have before the parliament right now,” Albanese told Melbourne’s 3AW radio on Friday, adding: “When it comes to housing, we’re focused on supply
Bit of parliamentary hypocrisy anyone. We need change.
- Forums
- Political Debate
- Fresh From The Stage 3 Tax Cuts Lie Here Is Albo's Next Trick - Negative Gearing.....
Fresh From The Stage 3 Tax Cuts Lie Here Is Albo's Next Trick - Negative Gearing....., page-47
-
- There are more pages in this discussion • 4 more messages in this thread...
You’re viewing a single post only. To view the entire thread just sign in or Join Now (FREE)
Featured News
Featured News
The Watchlist
SBW
SHEKEL BRAINWEIGH LTD
Dani Nadri, Country Manager Australia
Dani Nadri
Country Manager Australia
SPONSORED BY The Market Online