I guess following that logic, old shareholders need to give away...

I guess following that logic, old shareholders need to give away the difference if they purchased at a lower price and then later SP goes up. Otherwise it's not fair to new shareholders?

And yes, GF got a sweet deal from hindsight and so are a lot of old shareholders, but what if the Lithium sector did not boom and went down a bit, do you then expect anybody to pay GF back the loss amount? Or what's the argument then - advocating how GF got screwed by FFX and overpaying for the project?

Think about the logic again and do not be a hypocrite.