Financial Review
The carnage in the EV industry is only just getting started
Profits at the German auto giant Mercedes plunged last Friday as sales of its slick new range of electric vehicles went into freefall.
Porsche abandoned its sales targets for battery-powered cars amid waning demand from customers. Ford is losing nearly $US50,000 ($A76,000) on every EV it sells, while Tesla’s profits dropped 45 per cent. Meanwhile, battery manufacturers such as Germany’s Varta are getting wiped out.
It has become clear that the EV industry is on the brink of collapse. Hundreds of billions of euros, dollars and pounds have been pumped into this industry by political leaders and the subsidy junkies that surround them – and it is surely time they were held to account for the vast quantities of taxpayer cash that has been wasted.
Group net profits were down 21 per cent, mostly on falling sales of its new range of EVs.
Not-For-Syndication
In the last few days alone, there has been a steady stream of bad news from auto manufacturers. Mercedes, the company founded by Gottlieb Daimler that pioneered petrol-driven cars, is struggling to replicate that success in the battery version. Group net profits were down 21 per cent, mostly on falling sales of its new range of EVs. Earlier in the week, its great rival Porsche watered-down plans for its electric models.
Across the Atlantic, Ford reported that profits were down by 35 per cent in the latest quarter amid losses in its EV unit. And Tesla slashed prices and offered generous financing deals to try and revive flagging demand.
It is even worse for component manufacturers. Shares in Germany’s Varta are down by 70 per cent over the last month amid reports that the company may have to be rescued from bankruptcy after making heavy losses on batteries for hybrid sports cars.
This week, the Belgium chemicals group Umicore announced a €1.6 billion hit, as manufacturers warned of waning EV demand, and it postponed plans for a battery recycling plant.
The list goes on and on. In reality, the EV balance sheet looks to be awash with red ink. It is not hard to work out why. Costs are too high, as companies such as Ford have discovered, with electric cars much more expensive to produce than their traditional petrol rivals, and with shortages of critical materials pushing prices higher all the time.
There is too much capacity in the industry, with companies over-investing in too many factories and distribution centres. Demand for the end product has started to crumble, with consumers increasingly nervous over what may become obsolete technology. Insurance and maintenance costs are proving far higher than expected for many, once the vehicles are actually on the road.
And all that was before the Chinese entered the market with a new range of slick, cheap vehicles. The word “bloodbath” is used too often in business journalism. But right now, it may be the only one appropriate to describe the state of the Western EV industry.
Surely, it is time that political heads started to roll for the catastrophe that is now unfolding. Policymakers, under pressure from industrial and climate change lobby groups, picked this “winner” and spent eye-watering amounts of taxpayer money on it.
In 2019, France’s President Macron grandly announced a Franco-German plan to dominate battery production, with €700 million ($A1.1 billion) invested by France and another €1 billion in Germany.
The EU proudly boasts that €80 billion has been invested in the “EV value chain” as part of its Green New Deal, but when the books are finally opened it is unlikely they will be good.
The situation is even worse in the US. The Biden administration recently awarded nearly $US2 billion in grants to help restart or expand EV manufacturing and assembly sites across eight states, which feels like throwing good money after bad.
It has offered tens of billions in subsidies of more than $US7,000 per vehicle sold, and even more in building the infrastructure, including one $US7.5 billion scheme to install chargers that ended up with only seven actually built (which works out at more than $US1 billion each for what is basically just a plug).
Even in the UK, where the political class was largely too incompetent to back any projects, money was poured into the ill-fated Britishvolt project, and it remains to be seen how much is finally given to India’s Tata for its new EV battery factory in Somerset.
Economists have long warned that net zero provides a golden opportunity for waste and rent-seeking. But some elites chose not to listen. We should start holding them accountable. Lobbyists argued for the subsidies, civil servants supported them, and finance ministers enthusiastically virtue signalled with other people’s money.
But too much investment creates overcapacity. Markets are better at deciding which technologies work than politicians, and if there is a genuine demand for a product then no one has to receive a grant to manufacture it, since the potential profits to be made will be incentive enough.
The carnage in the EV industry is only just getting started, and already it has cost billions.
(20min delay)